“When I asked the baseball writers why they hadn’t elected me to the Hall of Fame, they told me they thought I was still playing.”
~ Bob Uecker
Well, another off-season distraction. Today the 2021 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot was announced. Members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America will begin to analyze and vote on the listed 25 players. Their selections will be announced on Tuesday, January 26, 2021 at 6 p.m. ET by Hall of Fame President Tim Mead. The event will be covered live by the MLB Network.
As with elections, there are rules:
An elector will vote for no more than ten (10) eligible candidates deemed worthy of election. Write-in votes are not permitted. Any candidate receiving votes of seventy-five percent (75%) of the ballots cast shall be elected to membership in the National Baseball Hall of Fame, located in Cooperstown, N.Y. There are other rules to be followed for both electors and for the candidates; the one that is the most controversial is Rule 5: Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character and contributions to the team(s) on which he played.
It is only fair to tell you up front, I am NOT in the BBWAA and therefore I do not have a vote in this process. Here is this year’s list and my humble comments on each:
Bobby Abreu - Received 5.5% last year, which was his 2nd on the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Barry Bonds - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 60.7% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Mark Buehrle - New to the ballot. He was one of the best left-handed pitchers of his era. Not over-powering, but he knew how to pitch. I‘d like to see him get in at some point, he’s right there. He gets my vote. Can’t have too many stand up guys in the Hall.
A.J. Burnett - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Roger Clemens - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 61% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Michael Cuddyer - New to the ballot. Probably a one and done candidate. I just don’t see him getting the votes.
Dan Haren - New to the ballot. Another player who will probably be a one and done.
LaTroy Hawkins - New to the ballot. Long career, but not HoF worthy.
Todd Helton - Received 29.2% last year, which was his 3rd year on the ballot. He was a great hitter but playing in Colorado probably hurts his chances. I go back and forth with his worthiness, but probably wouldn’t vote for him.
Tim Hudson - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Torii Hunter - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Andruw Jones - Received 19.4% last year, which was his 4th year on the ballot. He could surprise some folks by getting his vote percentage up, but I personally couldn’t vote for him.
Jeff Kent - Received 27.5% last year, which was his 8th year on the ballot. I don’t see him getting much higher a percentage. Another solid player, but not quite HoF.
Andy Pettitte - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 11.3% last year, which was his 3rd on the ballot.
Aramis Ramírez - New to the ballot. He just doesn’t have the numbers to be in the HoF.
Manny Ramírez - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 28.2% last year, which was his 5th on the ballot.
Scott Rolen - Received 35.3% last year, which was his 4th on the ballot. Again, not quite a HoF player in my book.
Curt Schilling - Received 70% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot. Numbers, probably, competitor absolutely, total idiot as probably. Let someone else vote for him.
Gary Sheffield - Received 30.5% last year, which was his 7th on the ballot. Another who had a long career, with solid numbers, but in my mind falls short.
Sammy Sosa - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 13.9% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Nick Swisher - New to the ballot. He’s a one and done. Nowhere near a HoF career. It’s a joke he’s even on the ballot.
Shane Victorino - New to the ballot. Another one and done.
Omar Vizquel - Received 52.6% last year, which was his 4th on the ballot. Omar would get my vote. Smooth fielder, an ambassador of the game. Not quite Ozzie Smith, but he was fun to watch.
Billy Wagner - Received 31.7% last year, which was his 6th on the ballot. Numbers aren’t quite there in my opinion, but he was a good one.
Barry Zito - New to the ballot. He could be surprising, but for me he lacks the big standout numbers.
So, I only voted for two. You may have noticed I didn’t include stats and metrics, sorry, but I saw all these players and felt my honest evaluation was the way to go. Of course, I ‘d enjoy hearing from you and who would get your vote.
An aside; if you haven’t, get yourself out to Cooperstown and visit the Hall. Allow at least two days. It is a magical place where history comes alive.
~ Coach Mike
~ Bob Uecker
Well, another off-season distraction. Today the 2021 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot was announced. Members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America will begin to analyze and vote on the listed 25 players. Their selections will be announced on Tuesday, January 26, 2021 at 6 p.m. ET by Hall of Fame President Tim Mead. The event will be covered live by the MLB Network.
As with elections, there are rules:
An elector will vote for no more than ten (10) eligible candidates deemed worthy of election. Write-in votes are not permitted. Any candidate receiving votes of seventy-five percent (75%) of the ballots cast shall be elected to membership in the National Baseball Hall of Fame, located in Cooperstown, N.Y. There are other rules to be followed for both electors and for the candidates; the one that is the most controversial is Rule 5: Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character and contributions to the team(s) on which he played.
It is only fair to tell you up front, I am NOT in the BBWAA and therefore I do not have a vote in this process. Here is this year’s list and my humble comments on each:
Bobby Abreu - Received 5.5% last year, which was his 2nd on the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Barry Bonds - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 60.7% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Mark Buehrle - New to the ballot. He was one of the best left-handed pitchers of his era. Not over-powering, but he knew how to pitch. I‘d like to see him get in at some point, he’s right there. He gets my vote. Can’t have too many stand up guys in the Hall.
A.J. Burnett - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Roger Clemens - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 61% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Michael Cuddyer - New to the ballot. Probably a one and done candidate. I just don’t see him getting the votes.
Dan Haren - New to the ballot. Another player who will probably be a one and done.
LaTroy Hawkins - New to the ballot. Long career, but not HoF worthy.
Todd Helton - Received 29.2% last year, which was his 3rd year on the ballot. He was a great hitter but playing in Colorado probably hurts his chances. I go back and forth with his worthiness, but probably wouldn’t vote for him.
Tim Hudson - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Torii Hunter - New to the ballot. Solid career, but not HoF worthy.
Andruw Jones - Received 19.4% last year, which was his 4th year on the ballot. He could surprise some folks by getting his vote percentage up, but I personally couldn’t vote for him.
Jeff Kent - Received 27.5% last year, which was his 8th year on the ballot. I don’t see him getting much higher a percentage. Another solid player, but not quite HoF.
Andy Pettitte - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 11.3% last year, which was his 3rd on the ballot.
Aramis Ramírez - New to the ballot. He just doesn’t have the numbers to be in the HoF.
Manny Ramírez - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 28.2% last year, which was his 5th on the ballot.
Scott Rolen - Received 35.3% last year, which was his 4th on the ballot. Again, not quite a HoF player in my book.
Curt Schilling - Received 70% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot. Numbers, probably, competitor absolutely, total idiot as probably. Let someone else vote for him.
Gary Sheffield - Received 30.5% last year, which was his 7th on the ballot. Another who had a long career, with solid numbers, but in my mind falls short.
Sammy Sosa - Absolutely not, PEDs. Received 13.9% last year, which was his 9th on the ballot.
Nick Swisher - New to the ballot. He’s a one and done. Nowhere near a HoF career. It’s a joke he’s even on the ballot.
Shane Victorino - New to the ballot. Another one and done.
Omar Vizquel - Received 52.6% last year, which was his 4th on the ballot. Omar would get my vote. Smooth fielder, an ambassador of the game. Not quite Ozzie Smith, but he was fun to watch.
Billy Wagner - Received 31.7% last year, which was his 6th on the ballot. Numbers aren’t quite there in my opinion, but he was a good one.
Barry Zito - New to the ballot. He could be surprising, but for me he lacks the big standout numbers.
So, I only voted for two. You may have noticed I didn’t include stats and metrics, sorry, but I saw all these players and felt my honest evaluation was the way to go. Of course, I ‘d enjoy hearing from you and who would get your vote.
An aside; if you haven’t, get yourself out to Cooperstown and visit the Hall. Allow at least two days. It is a magical place where history comes alive.
~ Coach Mike